Esop Or Phantom Share: Which Makes More Sense For Your Company?

Esop Or Phantom Share: Which Makes More Sense For Your Company?

In today's entrepreneurial scenario, businesses understand the importance of human resources. They properly reward employees with stock-based incentives such as the Employee Ownership Plan (ESOP) and stock-based incentives such as the relatively new method of allocating stock, Phantom Stock, and Stock Valuation Rights (SAR). 

Of these attractive employee benefits plans, Phantom Share is becoming more and more popular as a reward due to its increased flexibility and customization options. This article compares ESOP and Phantom Share and explains which one suits your business or employee needs. 

What is the ESOP? 

The Employee Stock Ownership Plan (ESOP) is one of the various incentives offered to employees through stock options. Participating employees exercise their right to purchase company shares at a pre-specified price and date, as stated in the quota.

The ESOP can bring significant financial benefits to employees as the business's reputation rises. In addition, you can pay stocks at the selling price during a liquidity event. 

 The popular ESOP plans are: 

 -Employee Stock Option Plan 

 -Employee stock purchase plan 

-Limited storage unit 

 -Stock appreciation right 

Is the ESOP suitable for your business? 

Key questions for companies sponsoring the ESOP, especially start-ups, revolve around employee numbers, net income, and annual sales. By evaluating each factor, the enterprise can decide whether to choose the ESOP. In addition, the cost of setting up and managing an ESOP is considerable and may not be beneficial to everyone. 

The ESOP is ideal for companies that want to engage their owners' executives in value sharing and ownership as their business grows. 

Some start-ups may prefer early employee stock options if there are uncertainties about sustainable growth to retain employees. 

Benefits of ESOP 

Employee loyalty by promoting personal responsibility and accountability. Improve your organization's performance through the interests of your company.

What is Phantom Share? 

Phantom Share is part of an employee benefits plan that gives participating executives the benefit of owning shares without receiving them. Phantom stock, also known as shadow stock, synthetic stock, or simulated stock, is a stock valuation right.

The plan grants the right to future cash payments and is usually associated with a valuation formula. The recipient will receive cash equal to the valuation of the shares until or during the valuation period. Full plan where the recipient receives the full amount of the shares on the settlement date. 

Is Phantom Share Suitable for Your Business? 

Many start-ups and organizations are aware of the impact of various equity offering plans on their employees. Phantom stocks are especially suitable for nonprofits and closely related businesses where the need for tangible assets is not feasible or practical. 

When employees have access to phantom stock, a "delay mechanism" occurs, delaying actual financial distribution over a long period of time. 

Start-ups and businesses that are expected to increase in value in the near future can also benefit from phantom share. Until the time of implementation, neither the employees involved nor the management will have to bear the costs. 

Employers seeking to minimize minority ownership and encourage employee ownership can find phantom stocks that help them reach their company's goals and maintain their talents. 

 Benefits of Phantom Share 

 -Participants are not shareholders, which simplifies stock allocation 

 -Flexibility as management decides terms  

 -This plan helps avoid complications of financial disclosure. This is useful if you have legal concerns. 

 -Retain key employees and invest in the company 

 -Set up costs and regulations are low, so less hassle 

ESOP or Phantom Stock-Which do you buy?

The economic benefits of ESOP and Phantom Share enrich both employees and employers. Therefore, to protect the interests of employers and shareholders, plans must be carefully selected and developed with the company's objectives in mind.

Which is better, ESOP or Phantom Stock? 

Both ESOP and Phantom Stock recognize that the company's most valuable asset is human resources, so it's a way to motivate employees in its strategic position. 

 However, you need to critically consider both options and understand the relevant strengths and weaknesses to answer this important question.

Why is it given? 

The Employee Ownership Plan (ESOP) was the most productive and powerful tool private companies use to incentivize key employees. This comprehensive social services service inspires employee satisfaction, motivation, and dedication and is a strong reason for long-term stays. The 

ESOP has many long-standing uses by businesses to ensure financial and social security, and there is also a sense of belonging to the workers who receive the ESOP. In addition, she has a strong commitment and responsibility for the company. 

 -Employee stock option plan 

 -Employee stock purchase plan 

 -Limited storage unit 

 -Stock appreciation right 

Phantom Share: Why is it given? 

Phantom stock is a fairly new way for businesses and businesses to incentivize and maintain executives. It is also used by entities to achieve the same goals as the ESOP and is in many ways similar to the ESOP but technically different from the ESOP. 

Also known as shadow stock, these are fictional and are given to employees who have a contractual deadline. The Phantom Stock has gained a tremendous position in recent years, primarily due to its flexibility. The company has complete freedom to build it according to its wishes. 

Since the shares have not actually been transferred, there is very little paperwork, and shareholders are not threatened or lose their sense of security or stability. Participating employees find it attractive and rewarding because they have no legal issues, are profitable, and only have to pay one tax. 

The value of these stocks fluctuates like real stocks but with minimal regulatory provisions. 

Key Factors Distinguishing ESOP and Phantom Stock: 


Company ownership is diluted. Employees as shareholders have a say in management. The employee bears the price of the stock. It is rigorously set in accordance with the terms of the 2013 SEBI and Companies Act; taxation.  


There is no dilution of the company's assets. Employees do not pay the stock, but the company bears it. Great flexibility because there are no legal obligations associated with it. One point of taxation.

Stock appreciation right 

Stock Valuation Rights (SAR) is similar to a phantom stock-based program. SAR is a form of bonus payment to employees that responds to an increase in the value of a company's stock over a specific period of time. Similar to employee stock options (ESOs), SAR is beneficial to employees when the company's stock price rises. The difference with SAR is that employees do not have to pay the strike price and receive an increase in stock or cash. The 

SAR is most commonly available to senior management and can be used as part of the retirement plan. The higher the value of the company, the higher the incentive. It also helps ensure employee retention, especially in the event of internal changes such as ownership changes or personal emergencies. The 

Phantom Stock Program is usually cashed back, providing some security for employees. This can lead to higher selling prices for companies if potential buyers are aware that senior management is stable.

If you are looking for any Employee stock option plan (ESOP) services or consultants in Noida, Delhi, Gurgaon or anywhere in India, write to us at Or Call On :(+91)-9711021268 +91-9310165114

- Share this post on -